Andersons Beats Estimates, But Stock and Cash Flow Lag
The Andersons has recorded four consecutive quarters of double-digit EPS beats, with the widest at 82.6%, yet the stock has fallen to $63.89 since a director's July sale at $80.53. Behind the earnings
Andersons Beats Estimates, But Stock and Cash Flow Lag
NEW YORK, October 10 —
Four consecutive EPS beats have not stopped The Andersons, Inc. (ANDE) from sliding to $63.89, now $16.64 below the price a director accepted selling shares in the open market last July. Trailing free cash flow of negative $109 million may be what those reported beats are not yet capturing.
- EPS surprise margins of 82.6%, 30.8%, 60.0%, and 45.2% over four straight quarters; analyst consensus target $88.33.
- Trailing free cash flow: negative $109 million. Operating cash flow: positive $322 million. The $431 million gap is capital expenditures.
- Director Bowe sold 3,534 shares at $80.53 on July 22; the stock has since fallen $16.64 to $63.89.
A Discount the Earnings Can't Close
The Andersons trades grain, fertilizer, and ethanol, a commodity merchandiser where 7.2% gross margins and $10.94 billion in trailing revenue are features, not bugs. Four consecutive quarters of double-digit EPS surprises, the widest an 82.6% beat, have earned it a forward P/E of 10.0x, well below the Consumer Retailing sector's 18.0x average and the 34.4x comparable peers fetch per recent analysis. That disconnect implies either the beats are cyclical and the market is looking through them, or analysts remain anchored too conservatively and the valuation hasn't caught up. The $88.33 consensus target suggests the latter, but the stock's recent 4.0% slide argues the former is winning.
The Capex Drain Underneath the EPS Beats
Behind the earnings beats lies a cash flow structure that complicates the narrative. The Andersons generated $322 million in operating cash flow over the trailing twelve months, yet capital expenditures consumed $431 million, pushing free cash flow to negative $109 million. Revenue fell 1.2% year-over-year and the balance sheet carries $0.90 billion in total debt against $0.07 billion in cash. Whether that capex is building out ethanol and agribusiness infrastructure or merely sustaining existing operations is the question a discounted cash flow analysis of ANDE would need to resolve first.
| Ticker | Mkt cap | Fwd P/E | 52-wk |
|---|---|---|---|
| ANDE | $2.2B | 10.0x | +52.0% |
| MGPI | $295M | 7.0x | -42.4% |
| GPRE | $1.0B | 8.4x | +44.0% |
| BG | $19.7B | 9.1x | +26.9% |
| ALCO | $285M | n/a | +13.6% |
| JJSF | $1.5B | 18.8x | -11.8% |
When the $88.33 Target Gets Its First Real Test
The July open-market sale by Director Patrick Bowe, 3,534 shares at $80.53, totaling roughly $284,593, has become an inadvertent price anchor; ANDE now sits $16.64 below that transaction. Net insider activity over the 90-day period records zero open-market purchases. Q3 2026 earnings will test whether capital expenditures moderated enough to narrow the free cash flow gap, and whether a fifth straight EPS beat draws a higher multiple against peers trading at 34.4x. That analyst consensus target requires progress on both. Run the free The Andersons, Inc. deep-dive → to track what Q3 delivers.
Basis Report is independent research for informational purposes. It is not investment advice and not a recommendation to buy or sell any security.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why has Andersons stock fallen despite EPS beats?
The Andersons has posted four straight EPS beats, yet its stock has fallen to $63.89 since a director's July sale at $80.53. The market may be skeptical that earnings beats are sustainable given the company's negative free cash flow and modest forward P/E of 10.0x.
What is Andersons' free cash flow problem?
Trailing free cash flow stands at negative $109 million, despite positive operating cash flow of $322 million. Capital expenditures of $431 million consumed more cash than operations generated, raising questions about whether capex is building infrastructure or sustaining existing operations.
How does Andersons stock value compare to peers?
The Andersons trades at a 10.0x forward P/E, well below the Consumer Retailing sector's 18.0x and comparable peers' 34.4x. The analyst consensus target of $88.33 suggests potential upside, but the recent 4.0% stock slide indicates the market remains unconvinced.
What business does Andersons operate?
The Andersons is a commodity merchandiser that trades grain, fertilizer, and ethanol, with 7.2% gross margins and $10.94 billion in trailing revenue. The company carries $0.90 billion in debt against minimal cash reserves of $0.07 billion.
When is the next catalyst for Andersons stock?
The next resolution point is Q3 2026 earnings, where capital expenditures and free cash flow metrics will be closely watched. The analyst consensus price target of $88.33 requires both a fifth consecutive EPS beat and evidence that the capital expenditure-free cash flow gap has narrowed.
Shares of The Andersons fell approximately 4.0% in recent trading to around $63.89, a price more than $16 below the level at which a director sold shares in an open-market transaction this past July—even as the company has beaten Wall Street EPS estimates in each of its last four reported quarters by margins as wide as 82.6%. The question the market has not yet answered is whether four consecutive large earnings beats can coexist with trailing free cash flow of negative $109 million.