Lyft Posts Third Straight EPS Miss as DOJ Sues for $53M
Lyft reported its third consecutive EPS miss, with a loss of $0.03 per share against consensus of $0.189, a 116.5% shortfall. The company generates $977 million in trailing free cash flow, creating a
Lyft Posts Third Straight EPS Miss as DOJ Sues for $53M
NEW YORK, November 15 —
Three consecutive EPS misses, the last a 116.5% shortfall, haven't stopped Lyft, Inc. (LYFT) from generating $977 million in trailing free cash flow, creating a credibility gap that a simultaneous $53 million DOJ disability lawsuit does nothing to close. The stock trades at a forward multiple that assumes recovery while every recent data point suggests the opposite.
- $977M trailing FCF; $1.90B cash against $1.29B debt; 8.3x forward earnings, consensus target $19.37, against a $16.98 close.
- DOJ seeks $53M in civil penalties plus mandatory accessibility changes; short interest at 21.5% of float.
A Miss That Keeps Getting Worse
It was an outlier. The forward multiple prices in a recovery the quarterly trend keeps postponing; a DCF model on current consensus requires exactly the inflection the numbers have yet to deliver.
The CFO Who Sold Lower the Second Time
The CFO transition, disclosed in a September 8-K, tells two stories. Outgoing CFO Erin Brewer sold 15,000 shares at $17.63 on August 24, then sold another 15,000 at $14.64 on September 24, a $2.99 drop between tranches that marks the second sale as something other than routine rebalancing. Six other insiders sold across late August and early September, bringing the 90-day net to $1.02 million in open-market sales against zero purchases. Incoming CFO Michael Zachary Brous received 255,861 shares in grants on October 20, a standard onboarding package, though share grants carry a different calculus than cash put on the line.
| Ticker | Mkt cap | Fwd P/E | 52-wk |
|---|---|---|---|
| LYFT | $6.4B | 8.1x | -21.3% |
| UBER | $142.3B | 15.8x | -24.3% |
| PINS | $11.0B | 8.4x | -25.0% |
| ZM | $29.1B | 15.7x | +21.9% |
| BYND | $101M | n/a | -82.8% |
| SNAP | $9.1B | 6.7x | -35.7% |
FCF Floor, ADA Ceiling
The floor is real: $1.90 billion in cash against $1.29 billion in debt, and trailing FCF across a platform that includes Express Drive rentals, shared bikes and scooters, and advertising services. The DOJ's suit alleging Lyft failed to provide required ADA accessibility for some passengers attacks the driver-rider matching platform directly; mandatory operating changes would arrive at a moment when earnings already can't meet consensus. With 21.5% of the float short, the market isn't waiting. Run the free Lyft, Inc. deep-dive →
Basis Report is independent research for informational purposes. It is not investment advice and not a recommendation to buy or sell any security.
Frequently Asked Questions
How much did Lyft miss on earnings?
Lyft reported an EPS loss of $0.03 per share against a consensus estimate of $0.189, a 116.5% shortfall. The prior two quarters showed misses of 41.8% and 7.1%, making this the third consecutive quarterly shortfall.
What is the DOJ lawsuit against Lyft?
The DOJ is seeking $53 million in civil penalties plus mandatory accessibility changes. The lawsuit alleges Lyft failed to provide required ADA accessibility for some passengers.
Why can't Lyft's earnings meet consensus?
Lyft generates $977 million in trailing free cash flow, creating a credibility gap where strong cash generation masks earnings weakness. The forward multiple of 8.3x prices in recovery the company hasn't yet delivered.
How short is Lyft stock?
Short interest is at 21.5% of the float; the market isn't waiting for the recovery the forward earnings multiple prices in.
Did Lyft's CFO sell stock?
Outgoing CFO Erin Brewer sold 15,000 shares at $17.63 in August, then another 15,000 at $14.64 in September. Six other insiders also sold across late August and September, totaling $1.02 million in net sales with no purchases.
Lyft's most recent quarter delivered a loss of $0.03 per share against a $0.189 consensus estimate — a miss of 116.5% and the worst of three consecutive quarterly shortfalls — while the U.S. Department of Justice simultaneously filed a $53 million disability discrimination lawsuit against the company. The stock has since been described in financial media as 'nosediving,' even as Lyft generates nearly $1 billion in annual free cash flow.
Sources & Filings