Annaly Beats Q3 EPS; Stock Below CEO's August Exit Price
Annaly's fourth consecutive EPS beat covered the dividend and pushed the stock up 3.22%. Yet it still trades below where the CEO sold shares in August, suggesting the market has priced in risks beyond
Annaly Beats Q3 EPS; Stock Sits Below CEO's August Exit
NEW YORK, October 21 —
Four consecutive EPS beats, a covered dividend, and a stock price that, 97 days on, still hasn't climbed back to where Annaly Capital Management, Inc. (NLY) CEO David Finkelstein cashed out: that is the contradiction the market handed investors after Q3 2026 results landed. The stock jumped 3.22% to $18.29 on October 20, and still sits $4.60 below the $22.89 at which Finkelstein sold $1.14 million in August.
- Q3 2026 adjusted EPS of $0.80 beat the $0.77 consensus by 3.9%, the fourth straight quarterly beat. [source]
- GAAP net loss was $1.00 billion, or $1.36 per share; adjusted revenue of $543.61M missed the consensus by 8.8%. [source]
- Shares are down 20.8% year-to-date through October 20, against a 12.4% gain for the S&P 500.
The Earnings Quality the Headline Obscures
Annaly is a mortgage REIT that uses short-term repo borrowing to fund leveraged holdings in agency mortgage-backed securities, mortgage servicing rights, non-agency whole loans, and commercial MBS. Its economics live in the spread between funding costs and asset yields, not in GAAP net income. On that operating measure, adjusted revenue nearly doubled year-over-year to $543.61 million, and earnings available for distribution of $0.80 per share exceeded the quarterly dividend, keeping the payout covered for a fourth straight quarter. Quarterly beat margins tell the same story: surprises of +1.4%, +2.7%, +5.3%, and +3.9% show the company outrunning Wall Street's models, not just clearing a sandbagged bar. AGNC Investment and Rithm Capital, Annaly's closest agency-REIT peers, both rose on the same session, AGNC by 4.3%, RITM by 2.4%, suggesting sector sentiment, not company-specific relief, drove part of the move.
What the CEO's Exit Priced In
The book-value story runs the other direction. AGNC management flagged that rising Treasury yields and wider agency MBS spreads pressured book value in the quarter, and the same dynamics hit Annaly, which holds a similarly constructed portfolio. Finkelstein's open-market sale of 50,000 shares at $22.89 on August 3, per the Q3 earnings release and Form 4 filing, occurred before the bulk of the year-to-date decline, at a price $0.26 above the current analyst consensus target of $22.63. Insider ownership sits at just 0.1% of shares outstanding, making any sale a significant signal. The analyst target implies 23.7% upside from the October 20 close; the CEO's exit price implies the market has already assigned a steeper discount than consensus models reflect.
| Ticker | Mkt cap | Fwd P/E | 52-wk |
|---|---|---|---|
| NLY | $13.7B | 5.8x | -14.1% |
| AGNC | $10.5B | 6.1x | -13.7% |
| CIM | $701M | 4.0x | -36.0% |
| MFA | $661M | 4.7x | -29.0% |
| EPD | $79.9B | 11.7x | +19.1% |
| ARR | $1.8B | 4.4x | -19.6% |
The October 28 Rate Decision as Next Checkpoint
With $127.53 billion in total debt against a $13.79 billion market cap, Annaly's spread economics are acutely sensitive to Fed policy. The Federal Reserve meeting expected to conclude October 28, 2026 is the next test: any shift in the rate path directly affects the repo-to-MBS carry that drives EAD. If that spread widens, the four-quarter beat streak can extend; if Treasury yields rise further and MBS spreads stay wide, book value erosion, the factor the stock has been pricing all year, remains the dominant signal. The number to watch next quarter is whether EAD holds at or above $0.80 per share with the dividend still covered. Run the free Annaly Capital Management, Inc. deep-dive →
Current fundamentals, valuation and filing history for Annaly Capital Management, Inc. (NLY) are tracked on its Basis Report page.
Basis Report is independent research for informational purposes. It is not investment advice and not a recommendation to buy or sell any security.
Frequently Asked Questions
Did Annaly beat Q3 earnings?
Yes, Annaly beat Q3 EPS with $0.80 per share versus $0.77 consensus, a 3.9% beat. This marked the company's fourth consecutive quarterly EPS beat, and earnings available for distribution exceeded the quarterly dividend, keeping the payout covered for the fourth straight quarter.
Why is Annaly stock down year to date?
Annaly shares are down 20.8% year-to-date through October 20, reflecting book value pressures. Rising Treasury yields and wider agency mortgage-backed securities spreads have pressured book value, the metric most closely watched by mortgage REIT investors.
Why did the CEO sell Annaly stock?
CEO David Finkelstein sold 50,000 shares at $22.89 on August 3. The stock now sits $4.60 below that price, and analyst consensus targets $22.63, suggesting the market has assigned a steeper discount than the CEO's exit price implied.
What is Annaly insider ownership percentage?
Insider ownership sits at just 0.1% of shares outstanding, making the CEO's sale particularly notable in context.
What's the next catalyst for Annaly stock?
The October 28 Federal Reserve meeting is the next major checkpoint. Any shift in the rate path directly affects the repo-to-mortgage-backed securities carry that drives earnings available for distribution, which investors expect to hold at or above $0.80 per share.
Annaly Capital Management reported Q3 2026 adjusted EPS of $0.80, beating estimates for the fourth consecutive quarter with earnings available for distribution again covering the quarterly dividend. The result sent shares up 3.22% to $18.29 — yet that close still sits $4.60 below the price at which CEO David Finkelstein sold $1.14 million in stock just 79 days earlier.