Barclays Flags CLF as Underweight Amid CFO Share Sale
NEW YORK, June 9 —
Cleveland-Cliffs' CFO sold nearly $2.9 million in company stock on June 5 at $13.41 per share. Four days later, Barclays placed the steelmaker on its cautious list with an Underweight rating, and shares dropped 4.3% as tariff-driven momentum faded. At $12.68, the stock sits below the CFO's exit price and above the $11 consensus analyst target. The market is caught between fading optimism and deteriorating fundamentals.
- CFO Celso Goncalves Jr. sold 214,308 shares at $13.41 on June 5, totaling $2,874,641 in an open-market transaction
- CLF's trailing gross margin is -2.9%: the company is generating negative gross profit before overhead or interest
- Shares trade at 28.9x forward earnings despite three consecutive quarters of per-share losses
The Insider's Exit Price
Insider sales rarely tell a complete story, but the mechanics here deserve scrutiny. CFO Celso Goncalves Jr. executed his sale at $13.41 on June 5, four days before Barclays issued its Underweight call. The stock now trades at $12.68, roughly 5.5% below his execution price. Insiders sell for many reasons, from diversification to tax planning. A CFO who runs the numbers daily chose to exit at a price the market has since moved below. That warrants attention.
Losing Money at the Top Line
Cleveland-Cliffs is large. Trailing revenue of $18.9 billion, a $7.2 billion market cap, year-over-year revenue growth of 6.3%. The scale is real. The income statement is harder to defend. A trailing gross margin of -2.9% means the company is generating negative gross profit: cost of goods sold exceeds revenue before a single dollar of overhead, depreciation, or interest charges appears on the page. Trailing free cash flow is negative $61 million. These are not soft-quarter anomalies. They are structural questions about whether the business can cover its own production costs at current steel prices.
A 29x Multiple on Three Straight Losses
The valuation math adds another layer of tension. CLF trades at 28.9x forward earnings, a premium multiple more appropriate for a growth compounder than a steelmaker running negative gross margins. The most recent quarter, reported in an April 20 8-K, showed a per-share loss of $0.50 against a consensus estimate of -$0.68. Two quarters prior: a loss of $0.43 versus an estimate of -$0.62. Beating a loss estimate by losing less than expected is not a recovery. Paying nearly 29x for that pattern is an act of faith the underlying numbers do not currently support.
What Changes the Thesis
The consensus analyst price target of $11 sits 13% below where the stock currently trades. Monday's 4.3% slide suggests the tariff-driven bounce is fading. A real improvement in steel prices, gross margin recovery back above zero, or a return to positive free cash flow would shift the calculus. Until one of those arrives, the CFO's exit at $13.41, the Barclays Underweight call, and a 28.9x forward multiple on persistent per-share losses all point in the same direction.
Run the free Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. deep-dive →
Basis Report does not hold positions in securities discussed. This is not investment advice.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Cleveland-Cliffs stock a buy or sell?
The article takes a medium-confidence bearish view: CLF trades at $12.68, above the $11 consensus analyst price target, while carrying a -2.9% gross margin, negative free cash flow, and a 28.9x forward P/E despite three consecutive quarters of per-share losses. The CFO's recent open-market sale above current prices and the Barclays Underweight call both reinforce the cautious case.
Why did the Cleveland-Cliffs CFO sell stock?
CFO Celso Goncalves Jr. sold 214,308 shares in an open-market transaction on June 5, 2026 at $13.41 per share, totaling $2.87 million, per Form 4 filings. The filing does not specify whether the sale was discretionary or pursuant to a pre-planned trading schedule. The sale preceded a Barclays Underweight rating by four days, with the stock now trading below the CFO's exit price.
What is Barclays' rating on Cleveland-Cliffs?
Barclays issued an Underweight rating on Cleveland-Cliffs as of June 9, 2026, placing the stock on its cautious list. The consensus analyst price target stands at $11, below the current trading price of $12.68, implying the stock is overvalued even after Monday's decline.
What does CLF's negative gross margin mean?
A gross margin of -2.9% means Cleveland-Cliffs spends more producing steel than it collects on sales, before operating or administrative expenses are counted. On $18.9 billion in trailing revenue, this represents a structural deficit at the production level. Recovery requires higher steel prices, lower input costs, or both.
Why does CLF have a 29x P/E if it's losing money?
Cleveland-Cliffs trades at 28.9x forward earnings because the market is pricing in a future recovery to profitability, not current results. The company has posted per-share losses for at least three consecutive quarters. If the anticipated margin reversal fails to materialize, the forward multiple is difficult to support at current prices.